The Review: Installation of the Kaleidescape system was straight forward and trouble free. The DVD storage server required only power and 100Base-T ethernet connections, as does the separate DVD reader. Because the server and reader do not have any audio/video ports they do not need to be located in close proximity to a media zone. These components can be placed where they are most convenient, anywhere on the wired ethernet network in the home. The separate Movie Player should be located in a media area where audio/video connections can drive a local display and sound system (unless they are used as source content to a centrally located audio/video switcher). Screen calibration was accomplished with Kaleidescape's on-screen calibration software. The server requires just under a minute and a half to boot and the players discover the host server without any end-user intervention.
The enhanced MAX MMS server by AMX is a significant improvement over their first release of their product earlier in the year in both hardware and software features. AMX's core strength is in their unified home automation control and hardware products, exemplified by the elegant Modero touchscreen panels. Although the MMS server can work as a stand-alone product independent of the need for Modero touchscreen panel and a NetLinx controller, it is quickly obvious that this is not the best scenario in which to deploy this product, because the controls are much more robust and engaging when using the Modero panel over the simpler onscreen display controlled by a wireless keyboard and mouse. AMX is also the only video server product offering digital audio as well as video distribution, although it is very likely that we will see Kaleidescape and Xperinet offer this same functionality in the near future.
The drawback to the Kaleidescape system is that they currently only support video distribution. Digital distribution of whole- house audio must be accomplished by choosing another manufacturer with its own unique, distinct set of software/hardware products. Kaleidescape recognizes this shortcoming and plans to add audio serving capabilities to their server in the near future. The other concern with the Kaleidescape is its high cost. Although it is certainly competitive with AMX, it is definitely more expensive than Xperinet or the Video ReQuest single-zone solution and will be at the high end of video server price point (most noticeable as other video serving products enter the market later this year and next year). But make no mistake, Kaleidescape is the Mercedes Benz of the digital video server world-once you've tried one its hard not to want one!
